Inspirational Story about Marriage that was Actually Horrifying

So one of my high school friends shared a story on Facebook this morning with the comment, ” Married or not… you should read this.” I thought it was going to be one of those lighthearted, inspirational stories, even if it started out with the husband asking for a divorce. (I Googled the first few lines to find the original source of this story. You can read it on Snopes.)

I’m reading through, and the husband was cheating on his wife and decided to leave her for another woman. The wife is angry, then tells him she’ll agree to the divorce in one month, but he has to carry her out of the bedroom every day like when they were first married. I’m thinking there’s going to be this really romantic ending where he realizes he loves his wife after all, and he’ll stay with her and live happily ever after.


It was almost that story. But then, when the husband has his epiphany moment, dumps his mistress, and runs home to reconcile with his wife, he finds her dead. She’d had cancer all along and didn’t want their son to have to deal with a divorce when she knew she was going to die.

I think this was supposed to be a cautionary tale about infidelity and not knowing what you’ve got until it’s gone, but it’s really far more horrifying to me, and I’ve been in a dreadful mood since I read it.

Okay, the husband did his wife wrong by cheating on her with the other woman. But the wife hid her cancer and her respective treatment from him the whole time. I know some people believe infidelity is unforgivable under any circumstances, but I honestly couldn’t fault the husband here for seeking intimacy elsewhere when his wife never even tried to communicate to him that she was dying. She never asked for support, never had him hold her hand during chemo. But the most unforgivable part in my mind is that she didn’t tell him for the sake of their son. (P.S. When I commented on the Facebook post that it was a horrible story, my comment was deleted.)

This woman was dying – she knew it would be soon, within a month – and she never tried to prepare her son or her son’s father for this. Her son was young enough to call them Mommy and Daddy. Were her affairs in order? Did she think at all about how her husband would now have to raise their son as a single parent – without any warning? (Yes, I know that people die suddenly and unexpectedly all the time, but she knew.) As morbid as it sounds, she could have blessed the relationship between her husband and this other woman so he wouldn’t be alone after she was gone. (I want my husband to find happiness again if I die before he does. Although I would prefer he finds a widow who understands his love for his deceased spouse.) She could’ve gotten to know the woman who was going to be her son’s surrogate mother.

I cannot villainize the husband in this story the way I think the original author intended to. He wasn’t innocent, that’s for sure, but the wife was actually selfish in her attempt at being a martyr.

The moral of the story at the end about building happiness and intimacy in your marriage is admirable – it’s just not the message I got from the story itself.

Be there for each other.

Talk to each other.

Create happiness as an individual, a couple, and a family. Together.

And for God’s sake, know when something is important enough that you can’t keep it to yourself, despite any distance you may sense between you and your spouse.

Just to balance out all the negativity I found in this story, I present to you a link my husband sent me that made me smile: The Nerdiest Proposal Ever.

Christina Gleason (972 Posts)

That’s me: Christina Gleason. I’m a professional copywriter, editor, and blogger. My company is called Phenomenal Content. (Hire me!) I’m a relatively high-functioning Aspie who also lives with Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS), depression, anxiety, and chronic pain. I am not ashamed to admit that I am in the care of a psychiatrist, who assures me that people in therapy are often better adjusted than “normal” people who are not, because at least we know what our issues are and are working on them. I’m a geek for grammar, fantasy, and select types of gaming, including World of Warcraft and Empire: Four Kingdoms. I hate vegetables. I have an intense phone phobia, so I’ll happily conduct business over email or IM instead.

No tag for this post.


  1. I agree with you. If B did something like that, I’d be devastated. (Granted, I wouldn’t be cheating on her to begin with.) Obviously, there was something seriously wrong with their marriage on both sides if he felt like he needed to go to someone else for affection and if she felt like she couldn’t talk to him about her life-threatening illness.
    TechyDad recently posted..Your Shape Fitness Evolved: Week 3 Diary and GiveawayMy Profile

  2. WOW! I never would have looked at it that way. I have read that a few times when people have posted it on FB. Definitely food for thought!
    Nicolle B. recently posted..Wow! Wow! Wubbzy! A Wuzzleburg Tale on DVD now! {giveaway}My Profile

  3. I thought the same thing when reading this on Facebook, it’s being passed around and to me it doesn’t even seem like a real story. Just a story to make people feel bad about themselves. Very disingenuous.

  4. Things don’t add up in this story. First, if she was on chemo her hair would have fallen out. Ou can’t hide being bald. Second, if she has a month to live, she wouldn’t be doing chemo. And suggesting that one bless an adulterous affair is the most assinine thing I’ve ever heard

  5. i understand there is an earlier version of the story, which ends with husband and wife being reconciled. there is no mention of cancer in the original story. This would make a lot more sense, and make the husband look like less of an unobservant idiot. the cancer thing is just too stupid for words.

  6. The real victim in this story is Jane.

  7. This is more of a moral story. Yes the wife could have told him, but she may have only found out and had a malignant systemic type. Which means fast and deadly, thus no treatments. Take the good and disregard the rest

  8. Keep in mind that the original story came from East Asia. The expectations of women are different there. Women are expected to keep a happy home and keep all troubling things away from the husband. Though not every family is like this my family is. My mother never ever told her husband when something was wrong. I’m glad I Am an American and don’t have to adhere to these expectations but many East Asian families oversees still follow this culture.

  9. Maybe she told him but he was too caught up in his affair to hear her. So she possibly gave up and suffered alone

Speak Your Mind


CommentLuv badge